In a report published today, the Women and Equalities Committee has found that LGBT people are expected to fit into systems that assume they are straight and cisgender far too often.
LGBT people are being let down in health and social care by structures and services that are not inclusive or designed with them in mind. A lack of leadership in Government, the NHS, and social services has also been highlighted as a factor contributing to this inaccessibility.
"While some of the disparities have been uncovered, many of the inequalities remain hidden, as data collection is poor and patchy across health and social care services."
The Women and Equalities Committee has found that deep inequalities exist in health outcomes for these communities and that treating them “the same” as non-LGBT people will not address these poor outcomes.
Same or similar needs; different treatment
While LGBT people generally have the same health and social care needs as the rest of the population, evidence shows that they do not always receive the same quality of service as non-LGBT people. Research also highlights that they have poorer health outcomes across many areas, for example, in levels of smoking, alcohol abuse, and even cancer outcomes.
While some of the disparities have been uncovered, many of the inequalities remain hidden, as data collection is poor and patchy across health and social care services. This is not acceptable: the NHS cannot formulate strategies to tackle inequalities if it does not know where to find them. The Committee therefore recommends that sexual orientation and gender identity monitoring should be made mandatory by the NHS and social care sector within the next 12 months.
Is the NHS Long Term Plan too generic?
The Committee also found that the NHS Long Term Plan is too generic to work effectively for LGBT people, who should be considered explicitly as part of health commissioning.
The Government admits this as part of the LGBT Action Plan published in 2018, but the two plans are not working together and there is no read-across. The Committee says the Equalities Office and DHSC should formulate and publish a list of the key inequalities in LGBT health that the NHS needs to be accountable for. This should then be included in the LGBT Action Plan, and both authorities should report back to the Committee annually on progress they are making in eliminating the identified inequalities.
A call to action for senior leaders
The Committee found that, while there is a lot of good will in health and social care services to make them LGBT-inclusive, the work is driven by committed individuals in a piecemeal fashion rather than by senior leaders in the NHS, councils, or the Government. There is little joined-up thinking and LGBT health is tacked on to existing policies, rather than be integrated into health and social care systems.
Witnesses to the Committee commented repeatedly on the importance of training of frontline staff. Staff training varies hugely between disciplines and the Committee is concerned that staff may not receive any training on LGBT issues during any of their professional training. Such training should be made mandatory and an integral part of all core medical professional training.
- See more: Can we aim higher than single-sex mental health wards?
- See more: Identity gatekeeping is deadly: why we need to stop platforming transphobia
Maria Miller MP, Chair of the Committee, said:
“We found a lot of good will in health and social care services to make them LGBT inclusive, and examples of good practice that must be shared and embedded in our services. But unfortunately, the best will in the world won’t change the systemic failings in areas such as data-collection and training that are leading to poorer experience when accessing services, and to poorer health outcomes for LGBT people.
“This can never be acceptable. LGBT-specific services play an essential role in the health and social care services for the moment and must be maintained as long as that’s necessary, but mainstream services must move now ensure that they are inclusive and are effectively identifying and taking into account the needs of the LGBT communities.
"We must eliminate the unacceptable inequalities in health outcomes that glare out wherever you look.”